Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya vs. Ye Maaya Chesave

Nag. Silambarasan and Samantha

Come February 26 and we’ll have two releases in two languages. But, they both are of the same story. Gautham Vasudev Menon’s romance drama which initiated as Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya (Tamil) and then as Ye Maaya Chesave (Telugu) will face the litmus test as it has been in production for a while and the hype it has raised is inevitable as it has for every other Gautham Vasudev Menon film. But, what is the noticeable difference in both films?

One word – Cast.

Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya has the so-called Kollywood Bad Boy, Silambarasan (who gets his much wanted breakthrough) and Trisha Krishnan (who’s trying to revive her career). These two stars have been in the industry since 2001. Silambarasan’s career can be explained easily as the 27-year-old hasn’t proved himself so far other than romance a lot of women (as in Manmadhan) or impress with his dance moves (Silambattam). Trisha Krishnan on the other side has proved a lot in means of glamour and a little in terms of acting.

On the other side of the road, we have the young Nag Chaitanya who after a disappointing debut in Josh is desperate for a hit as he hails from a family of actors (son of Nagarjuna and stepson to Amala). Playing the Telugu version of Trisha is Samantha Ruth Prabhu who has acted in films like Baana Kaathadi and Moscowvin Kaaveri (they haven’t yet released). Logically, this becomes her debut.

Famous critics have argued that a trailer is a deceiving medium to lure us into the cinema halls only to suffer the fate of a bad film. The trailers of both films seem impressive (as it is the same content in both languages).  However, Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya excels in terms of performances. Silambarasan’s voice in the last dialogue in the trailer “Poi kalyanam pannikko Jessie, Nee onnum permission kekka varalala” is spoken with much emotion that he really felt it. But, Nag Chaitanya fails to even evoke a little interest through his stony vocals and rigid expressions. Man! Nag doesn’t even know the boxing stance. He holds his hands crossed while Silambarasan has them equally distanced.

Trisha and Samantha Ruth Prabhu fare well on both grounds. But, remember Trisha knows a little about acting while Samantha is beautiful indeed, but debuting. If she proves it well, she would be the next big thing. For once, I’d agree that we are relating two films by means of story. But, when it comes to performances, where do we stand? Where do they stand?

Many preferred Aamir Khan and not Surya. They found the eccentric richness in Aamir quite natural while Surya had to utter a lot of English phrases and undergo a total facelift (which he hasn’t yet come out of) to match the role of Sanjay Ramasamy. The battle at the box office will turn hardcore on February 26. But is this any good? Will Gautham deliver after a hapless remake (Pachaikili Muthucharam) and a customized biopic (Varanam Aayiram)? Love stories usually make their way into the cash registers, but this “inspired by a few events in the director’s life” story will certainly be tricky. Gautham has even stated that he has two endings – one tragic and the other happy. So, if the tragic one doesn’t work out, he’ll use the happy one. Is this what we are? We burn down screens if the hero dies and tear posters if the heroine doesn’t marry the hero. We are still subdued by the creators who take the opportunity gamble with our minds. Come on, lads! We aren’t rich to watch a film twice.

Trailer of Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya:

Trailer of Ye Maaya Chesave:


9 thoughts on “Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya vs. Ye Maaya Chesave

  1. Santosh March 3, 2010 / 01:39

    As I have seen both the movies, ye maaya chesave, which has a fresh feeling where as Vinnai Thandi Varuvaya is also good, but a little disappointing, as we all know the acting skills of both simbu and trisha’s performances, but overall both r hit, but i vote for ye maaya chesave….

  2. hari March 10, 2010 / 04:32

    this film is fentastic and story`was very naturel

    hari mvsr143

  3. tkreddy March 12, 2010 / 04:02

    The difference is the end. happy end in telugu and sad in tamil. performance wise i think this is a fresh love story i vote for YMC

  4. Binu April 21, 2010 / 17:42

    I have seen both “Ye Maaya Chesave” & “Vinnaithaandi Varuvaaya”. even though both are good, i Liked Ye Maaya Chesave more.

  5. Suchi January 14, 2011 / 07:49

    VTV was a bit drab, but Ye Maaya Chesave was fresher, had a lot more life, and the characters made more sense. Bad casting ruined VTV a bit for me. Simbu was ok, much better than usual. Trisha as usual brought nothing to the table. She’s too self conscious, she needs to step out and get into a character, not wonder what she looks like doing it.

  6. Sai Kiran February 12, 2014 / 14:41

    To me Ye Maaya Chesave was… Great.. I know this comment by me after a long time of release of the both version… But I Love Telugu version -Ye Maaya Chesave….

  7. mayank chaubey August 6, 2014 / 07:36

    I’ve watched all 3 movies: Vtv, Ymc and Ekk deewana tha. For edt I have no words to say how magical this movie is and better than Vtv. But right after watching Ymc the magic became 10 times more. Even I watched the telugu version with the help of English subtitals. I wish I felt much better if I would have known Telugu and Tamil along with Hindi in the real language the movies have released with. So my vote goes to Ymc then Edt and at last Vtv.

  8. meena November 29, 2014 / 07:10

    vtv always best

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s